Skip to content
Free Shipping Over $70
Country/region
Antigua & Barbuda (XCD $)
Argentina (USD $)
Aruba (AWG ƒ)
Australia (AUD $)
Austria (EUR €)
Bahamas (BSD $)
Barbados (BBD $)
Belgium (EUR €)
Belize (BZD $)
Bermuda (USD $)
Bolivia (BOB Bs.)
Brazil (USD $)
British Indian Ocean Territory (USD $)
British Virgin Islands (USD $)
Canada (CAD $)
Cayman Islands (KYD $)
Chile (USD $)
Christmas Island (AUD $)
Colombia (USD $)
Cook Islands (NZD $)
Costa Rica (CRC ₡)
Curaçao (ANG ƒ)
Cyprus (EUR €)
Denmark (DKK kr.)
Dominican Republic (DOP $)
Ecuador (USD $)
El Salvador (USD $)
Falkland Islands (FKP £)
Faroe Islands (DKK kr.)
Fiji (FJD $)
Finland (EUR €)
France (EUR €)
Germany (EUR €)
Greece (EUR €)
Greenland (DKK kr.)
Grenada (XCD $)
Guatemala (GTQ Q)
Iceland (ISK kr)
Ireland (EUR €)
Italy (EUR €)
Jamaica (JMD $)
Luxembourg (EUR €)
Macao SAR (MOP P)
Maldives (MVR MVR)
Malta (EUR €)
Mexico (USD $)
Netherlands (EUR €)
New Zealand (NZD $)
Nicaragua (NIO C$)
Norfolk Island (AUD $)
North Macedonia (MKD ден)
Norway (USD $)
Panama (USD $)
Paraguay (PYG ₲)
Peru (PEN S/)
Pitcairn Islands (NZD $)
Poland (PLN zł)
Portugal (EUR €)
Qatar (QAR ر.ق)
Russia (USD $)
San Marino (EUR €)
Saudi Arabia (SAR ر.س)
Spain (EUR €)
St. Lucia (XCD $)
St. Martin (EUR €)
St. Pierre & Miquelon (EUR €)
St. Vincent & Grenadines (XCD $)
Svalbard & Jan Mayen (USD $)
Sweden (SEK kr)
Switzerland (CHF CHF)
Turks & Caicos Islands (USD $)
U.S. Outlying Islands (USD $)
United Arab Emirates (AED د.إ)
United Kingdom (GBP £)
United States (USD $)
Vatican City (EUR €)
Wallis & Futuna (XPF Fr)
Yemen (YER ﷼)
Update country/region
Country/region
United States (USD $)
Antigua & Barbuda
(XCD $)
Argentina
(USD $)
Aruba
(AWG ƒ)
Australia
(AUD $)
Austria
(EUR €)
Bahamas
(BSD $)
Barbados
(BBD $)
Belgium
(EUR €)
Belize
(BZD $)
Bermuda
(USD $)
Bolivia
(BOB Bs.)
Brazil
(USD $)
British Indian Ocean Territory
(USD $)
British Virgin Islands
(USD $)
Canada
(CAD $)
Cayman Islands
(KYD $)
Chile
(USD $)
Christmas Island
(AUD $)
Colombia
(USD $)
Cook Islands
(NZD $)
Costa Rica
(CRC ₡)
Curaçao
(ANG ƒ)
Cyprus
(EUR €)
Denmark
(DKK kr.)
Dominican Republic
(DOP $)
Ecuador
(USD $)
El Salvador
(USD $)
Falkland Islands
(FKP £)
Faroe Islands
(DKK kr.)
Fiji
(FJD $)
Finland
(EUR €)
France
(EUR €)
Germany
(EUR €)
Greece
(EUR €)
Greenland
(DKK kr.)
Grenada
(XCD $)
Guatemala
(GTQ Q)
Iceland
(ISK kr)
Ireland
(EUR €)
Italy
(EUR €)
Jamaica
(JMD $)
Luxembourg
(EUR €)
Macao SAR
(MOP P)
Maldives
(MVR MVR)
Malta
(EUR €)
Mexico
(USD $)
Netherlands
(EUR €)
New Zealand
(NZD $)
Nicaragua
(NIO C$)
Norfolk Island
(AUD $)
North Macedonia
(MKD ден)
Norway
(USD $)
Panama
(USD $)
Paraguay
(PYG ₲)
Peru
(PEN S/)
Pitcairn Islands
(NZD $)
Poland
(PLN zł)
Portugal
(EUR €)
Qatar
(QAR ر.ق)
Russia
(USD $)
San Marino
(EUR €)
Saudi Arabia
(SAR ر.س)
Spain
(EUR €)
St. Lucia
(XCD $)
St. Martin
(EUR €)
St. Pierre & Miquelon
(EUR €)
St. Vincent & Grenadines
(XCD $)
Svalbard & Jan Mayen
(USD $)
Sweden
(SEK kr)
Switzerland
(CHF CHF)
Turks & Caicos Islands
(USD $)
U.S. Outlying Islands
(USD $)
United Arab Emirates
(AED د.إ)
United Kingdom
(GBP £)
United States
(USD $)
Vatican City
(EUR €)
Wallis & Futuna
(XPF Fr)
Yemen
(YER ﷼)
Facebook
Bluesky
Instagram
YouTube
Home
Shop the Goods
Shop the Goods
Shop All of Our Goods
Gift Sets & Bundles
Hot Sauce
Fat Toad Farm Goat's Milk Caramel
Maple Sweetened Baked Goods
Whole Seed Mustards
Salsas & Sauces
Heady Topper Collection
As Seen On Hot Ones Collection
Award Winning Collection
Guster Collection
Merch
The Pantry
Collaborations
Collaborations
Genersaucity Charities
Small Farm & Business Collaborations
Recipes
Recipes
Butterfly Bakery of Vermont Recipes & Pairings
Fat Toad Farm Caramel Recipes & Pairings
Services & Wholesale
Services & Wholesale
Wholesale Purchasing
White Label
Custom Copacking
Corporate Gifts
Wedding Favors
About Us
About Us
Butterfly Bakery of Vermont's Story
Fat Toad Farm's Story
In the News
For the Media
Customer Reviews
Retired Hot Sauces
The Toad & The Butterfly - a Blog
Contact
Contact
Visit, Call or Follow Us
Common Questions
Shipping & Pickup
Events We're Attending
Log In
Facebook
Bluesky
Instagram
YouTube
Country/region
United States (USD $)
Antigua & Barbuda
(XCD $)
Argentina
(USD $)
Aruba
(AWG ƒ)
Australia
(AUD $)
Austria
(EUR €)
Bahamas
(BSD $)
Barbados
(BBD $)
Belgium
(EUR €)
Belize
(BZD $)
Bermuda
(USD $)
Bolivia
(BOB Bs.)
Brazil
(USD $)
British Indian Ocean Territory
(USD $)
British Virgin Islands
(USD $)
Canada
(CAD $)
Cayman Islands
(KYD $)
Chile
(USD $)
Christmas Island
(AUD $)
Colombia
(USD $)
Cook Islands
(NZD $)
Costa Rica
(CRC ₡)
Curaçao
(ANG ƒ)
Cyprus
(EUR €)
Denmark
(DKK kr.)
Dominican Republic
(DOP $)
Ecuador
(USD $)
El Salvador
(USD $)
Falkland Islands
(FKP £)
Faroe Islands
(DKK kr.)
Fiji
(FJD $)
Finland
(EUR €)
France
(EUR €)
Germany
(EUR €)
Greece
(EUR €)
Greenland
(DKK kr.)
Grenada
(XCD $)
Guatemala
(GTQ Q)
Iceland
(ISK kr)
Ireland
(EUR €)
Italy
(EUR €)
Jamaica
(JMD $)
Luxembourg
(EUR €)
Macao SAR
(MOP P)
Maldives
(MVR MVR)
Malta
(EUR €)
Mexico
(USD $)
Netherlands
(EUR €)
New Zealand
(NZD $)
Nicaragua
(NIO C$)
Norfolk Island
(AUD $)
North Macedonia
(MKD ден)
Norway
(USD $)
Panama
(USD $)
Paraguay
(PYG ₲)
Peru
(PEN S/)
Pitcairn Islands
(NZD $)
Poland
(PLN zł)
Portugal
(EUR €)
Qatar
(QAR ر.ق)
Russia
(USD $)
San Marino
(EUR €)
Saudi Arabia
(SAR ر.س)
Spain
(EUR €)
St. Lucia
(XCD $)
St. Martin
(EUR €)
St. Pierre & Miquelon
(EUR €)
St. Vincent & Grenadines
(XCD $)
Svalbard & Jan Mayen
(USD $)
Sweden
(SEK kr)
Switzerland
(CHF CHF)
Turks & Caicos Islands
(USD $)
U.S. Outlying Islands
(USD $)
United Arab Emirates
(AED د.إ)
United Kingdom
(GBP £)
United States
(USD $)
Vatican City
(EUR €)
Wallis & Futuna
(XPF Fr)
Yemen
(YER ﷼)
Log in
Search
Search
Log in
0
0 items
Subtotal
$ 0.00
Home
Shop the Goods
Shop All of Our Goods
Gift Sets & Bundles
Hot Sauce
Fat Toad Farm Goat's Milk Caramel
Maple Sweetened Baked Goods
Whole Seed Mustards
Salsas & Sauces
Heady Topper Collection
As Seen On Hot Ones Collection
Award Winning Collection
Guster Collection
Merch
The Pantry
Collaborations
Genersaucity Charities
Small Farm & Business Collaborations
Recipes
Butterfly Bakery of Vermont Recipes & Pairings
Fat Toad Farm Caramel Recipes & Pairings
Services & Wholesale
Wholesale Purchasing
White Label
Custom Copacking
Corporate Gifts
Wedding Favors
About Us
Butterfly Bakery of Vermont's Story
Fat Toad Farm's Story
In the News
For the Media
Customer Reviews
Retired Hot Sauces
The Toad & The Butterfly - a Blog
Contact
Visit, Call or Follow Us
Common Questions
Shipping & Pickup
Events We're Attending
Log In
Butterfly Bakery of Vermont & Fat Toad Farm
In The News
Read the latest news and award announcements for Butterfly Bakery of Vermont and Fat Toad Farm.
Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
Best Food and Beverage Gifts for 2026
Parade
Kelli Acciardo | November 1, 2026
Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
This Reviewer Has Tried Over 500 Hot Sauces — These 5 Scored a Perfect 10
Food & Wine
Merlyn Miller | September 1, 2026
Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
Hot sauce could heat up Vermont farmer profits
WCAX News
Cassie Lathrope | July 16, 2026
Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
Vermont bakery’s hot sauce goes viral for community-grown ingredients and celebrity spotlight
NBC News 5
Adrian Pastor | April 10, 2026
Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
See Butterfly Bakery of Vermont featured in the State of Vermont's Working Lands Enterprise Initiative 2025 Impact Report
State of Vermont
February 9, 2026
Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
Specialty Food Association Announces 75 sofi™ Gold Award Finalists Ahead of Winter FancyFaire* 2026
Specialty Food Association
Member Press Release | October 15, 2025
Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
The Hot Sauces Chefs Swear By - Including a Surprise ‘Hot Ones’ Pick
Food & Wine
Amelia Schwartz | June 27, 2025
Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
Butterfly Bakery of Vermont Wins Gold at the 2025 European Hot Sauce Awards
European Hot Sauce Awards
June 2025
Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
Vermont Grown: A show with EatVT's Rocket and Claire Georges from Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
WDEV
Travels With Charlie | June 2, 2025
Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
Butterfly Bakery of Vermont Wins Gold at the 2025 World-Wide Mustard Competition
The National Mustard Museum
May 2025
Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
USDA grants inject more than $3 million into Vermont's local food production economy
Yahoo! News / The Burlington Free Press
Dan D'Ambrosio | May 8, 2025
Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
This Is Our Home: Barre Town
WPTZ News
Adrian Pastor | April 22, 2025
Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
On ‘Hot Ones,’ Butterfly Bakery Showcases Vermont Chiles
Seven Days
Melissa Pasanen | March 4, 2025
Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
I'm a hot sauce CEO who bulk-ordered glass bottles to get ahead of tariffs. Storage proved too much of a headache
Business Insider
Dominick Reuter | February 18, 2025
Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
Hot Ones: Celebs sweat it out over Barre-made sauces
Times Argus News
Peter Cobb | January 31, 2025
Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
Vermont hot sauce featured on YouTube show ‘Hot Ones’
WCAX News
Cat Viglienzoni | January 30, 2025
Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
Vermont Chili Peppers Are Lighting Up Celebrities on Season 26 of Hot Ones
Specialty Food Association
Member Press Release | January 23, 2025
Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
Vermont hot sauce to return to YouTube show 'Hot Ones'
WPTZ News
Cameron Silloway | January 20, 2025
Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
The Best Hot Sauce, According to Bon Appétit Editors
Bon Appetit
Li Goldstein and Megan Wahn | September 19, 2024
Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
From Chocolate to Chili Peppers
Vermont Sustainable Jobs Fund
Kelly Nottermann | November 30, 2023
Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
Spice up your life (or at least food) at Barre's Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
Vermont Public
Liam Elder-Connors | May 2, 2023
Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
Vermont’s Butterfly Bakery spices up new season of hit show ‘Hot Ones’
VT Digger
Dominic Minadeo | February 24, 2023
Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
Butterfly Bakery Expands: Now Carries Goats Milk Caramel
The Bridge
Lauren Milideo | September 29, 2022
Fat Toad Farm
Fat Toad Farm Sold to Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
Seven Days
Anne Wallace Allen | August 30, 2022
Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
Take the Heat: Seven Days Staffers Sample Five Local Hot Sauces
Seven Days
Margaret Grayson | July 13, 2021
Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
Butterfly Bakery: Patron Saint of Vermont Chili Peppers
Edible Vermont
Staff | April 3, 2021
Fat Toad Farm
Making it in Vermont: Fat Toad Farm is keeping caramel simple
VT Digger
Anne Wallace Allen | December 8, 2019
Fat Toad Farm
The Best Sweet Accompaniments of the Year!
Culture Magazine
Rebecca Haley-Park and Molly McDonough | December 28, 2018
Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
Vermont Hot Sauce Makers Feel the Burn
Seven Days
Suzanne Podhaizer | August 23, 2017
Fat Toad Farm
Caramel is the new chocolate? Fancy new food trends
The Today Show
Sissy Biggers | July 24, 2015
Fat Toad Farm
FedEx Awards Fat Toad Farm Small Business Grant
FedEx
Staff Press Release | March 25, 2014
Fat Toad Farm
Vermont farm makes sumptuous Mexican sauce with goat’s milk
The Boston Globe
Rachel Ellner | September 25, 2012
Fat Toad Farm
One Ingredient, Many Ways: Goat Cheese
Saveur
Leah Koenig | March 14, 2012
Fat Toad Farm
A Taste of Place: Exploring the Vermont Cheese Trail
The Christian Science Monitor
Joanne Ciccarello | November 3, 2010
Fat Toad Farm
6 New Ways to Enjoy Goat's Milk
Bon Appetit
Amy Albert | September 20, 2010
Fat Toad Farm
Sticky Sweets | Say It With Caramel
New York Times Magazine
Charlotte Druckman | February 8, 2010
Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
Butter-free at Butterfly
Seven Days
Suzanne Podhaizer | November 8, 2006
← Previous
1
Next →
Recently Viewed
Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
Shopping Cart
Spend
[remain]
more to receive
Free Shipping
!
Congratulations!
You've got
Free Shipping!
Free
Shipping
Please note*:
[product_count] product(s) in your cart excluded from the free shipping option.
Your cart is empty
Let's fill it with
YUM!
Check out our best selling collections!
Fat Toad Farm Goat's Milk Caramel
Hot Sauces
Gift Sets & Bundles
Award Winners & Best Sellers
Continue shopping
Have an account?
Log in
to check out faster.
Loading...
You may also like
Days
Hours
Minutes
Seconds